When choosing an assistant for a child, it’s easy to get confused between a nanny and a governess. Both specialists work with children, but their goals, work formats, and results differ. Understanding these differences helps to select someone who truly meets the family’s needs — whether it’s care and safety or education and skill development.
Nanny: Care, Routine, Safety
A nanny provides daily supervision for the child, maintains a familiar routine, and ensures comfort.
Main responsibilities of a nanny:
- supervision at home and during walks, accompanying to activities and classes;
- assistance with routine: sleep, nutrition, hygiene;
- games, reading, simple developmental activities;
- order in the child’s room and personal belongings.
A nanny is relevant for toddlers and in situations where stable daily support is required: regular walks, illnesses, adapting the child to a new person.
Governess: Education, Discipline, Development
A governess is an educator in the family. She not only accompanies the child but also systematically develops skills: thinking, speech, preparation for school.
Main responsibilities of a governess:
- planning and conducting lessons;
- assistance with homework and organizing study time;
- fostering independence, attention, and perseverance;
- providing feedback on progress and difficulties.
A governess is particularly useful for preschoolers and younger schoolchildren when the structure of lessons and monitoring results are important.
Key Differences: A Brief Checklist
Purpose of Work
Nanny — supervision, safety, routine.
Governess — education, development, results.
Work Format
A nanny often works long shifts and covers the entire day.
A governess frequently works in blocks: lessons plus accompaniment.
Result
For a nanny — a calm day and stable routine.
For a governess — skill acquisition and educational progress.
A common mistake is hiring a nanny and expecting systematic school preparation or inviting a governess when routine and gentle adaptation are primary.
How to Choose a Specialist
The choice begins with answering the question: what needs to change in the next 1–2 months — routine, accompaniment, development, or school preparation. Next, consider the child’s age, family schedule, and work format.
When a nanny is often chosen:
- the child is small, walks, sleep, and nutrition are important;
- regular supervision is needed for the whole day;
- priority is a calm and safe routine.
When a governess is often needed:
- preparation for school or assistance with the curriculum is required;
- there are difficulties with concentration and independence;
- a lesson plan and clear dynamics are needed.
Interview Questions
- How are boundaries and rules established, and how do you respond to whims?
- What does a typical day or lesson look like?
- How is progress recorded and feedback provided?
- What is fundamentally not included in the responsibilities?
- How to act in unforeseen situations?
Conclusion
Nannies and governesses solve different tasks: the former is responsible for care, safety, and routine, while the latter is responsible for education and skill development. The more precisely the family’s request is formulated, the higher the chance of finding a specialist who truly fits the child and reduces tension in daily life.
Leave a comment